Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

News

The CBA Briefing: 17th November 2026

The CBA Briefing17th November 2026
The CBA Briefing: 17th November 2026

Let there be absolutely NO doubt: the Criminal Bar Association is fundamentally opposed to the proposed restrictions on the right to jury trial.

In this edition

  • Domestic Abuse Best Listing Scheme: effective January 2027
  • Bar Conference 2026
  • ‘Myths and stereotypes’ in the news
  • Reporting of PECS delays
  • The Skills of Modern Advocacy: new book by Jaime Hamilton KC and Nigel Booth (with discount code)
  • Courts and Tribunals Bill: House of Lords Committee Stage Debate (first session)
  • Criminal Law Week: updates (issue 41)

Domestic Abuse Best Listing Scheme

As part of the National Listing Framework, the Domestic Abuse Listing Scheme has now been published on the Judiciary website.

A copy of the scheme can be found here.

Further guidance can be found here.

This scheme will take effect on 4th January 2027. For many cases of domestic abuse it will transform pre-charge work and lead to the expedited hearing of cases. Cases will be actively managed both in the Magistrates’ courts and the Crown Court with the aims of reducing avoidable delay and giving victims and defendants greater certainty.

It applies to single-defendant cases according to eligibility criteria which are set out in the scheme document. The identification of cases which are within scope should take place at the latest by the first hearing in the magistrates’ court.

The categories of offences which are potentially within scope are wide, including violence, controlling and coercive behaviour, breach of protective orders, harassment/stalking, public order offences, criminal damage, theft/fraud arising from financial abuse and image-based abuse.

In magistrates’ courts, all relevant cases can qualify regardless of bail status or trial length. The first magistrates’ court hearing must address plea, issues, witnesses and applications, with trials aimed to be listed within 8–12 weeks.

In the Crown Court, eligibility is limited to defendants on bail and trials expected to last no more than three days. PTPHs should occur within four weeks of sending, with trials concluded within 12–14 weeks.

The Scheme makes victim safety a central consideration. Bail conditions, protective measures, special measures and support needs should be considered throughout. Priority is also given to the early identification of issues and the minimisation of adjournments.

The Scheme builds on the proven success of the pilot project at Preston Crown Court. It is a welcome addition towards the National Listing Framework’s central task of reducing the human impact of court delay.

Bar Conference 2026

The Bar Conference 2026 took place in London on Saturday 14th November. This was a sold-out event with keynote addresses from the Lord Chancellor, Alex Norris MP, the Lady Chief Justice, Baroness Sue Carr, Michael Mansfield KC, and Bar Council Chair Kirsty Brimelow KC.

Topics discussed included artificial intelligence in legal practice; developments in the role of expert witnesses; the experiences of disabled barristers and the evolving landscape of access, inclusion, and support; open justice, the balance between transparency and protecting the vulnerable; and developments following the Harman Review on bullying, harassment and sexual harassment. Baroness Carr led a panel discussion titled: “Ask the Judges” discussing the role of judges, the pathway to appointment and the importance of the judiciary.

The event was closed with a passionate speech by barrister turned media personality Robert Rinder MBE, who spoke about the importance of the work of the bar to society, and the protection of the rule of law. He told the conference of his pride at being a barrister and his admiration of the Bar’s campaigning work on the Courts and Tribunals Bill and the protection of trial by jury. He said:

“The answer to a justice system in crisis can never be to diminish the very rights it exists to protect.”

‘Myths and stereotypes’ in the news

Following the trial of Russell Brand, there has been a considerable amount of media comment on the (ab)use of ‘myths and stereotypes’ in cases of rape and serious sexual offending.

Both lawyers and judges should welcome the spotlight which has fallen on this issue. It gives us the opportunity to talk about the decades of work undertaken by lawyers, judges, academics, survivors and other campaigners to develop a sophisticated legal framework which strives to ensure that a complainant’s evidence is judged by fair standards, not on the basis of misplaced prejudice and stereotypes. It allows us to talk about the way in which criminal law has been carefully developed, so that evidence is tested and judged in ways which are relevant and appropriate, whilst at the same time protecting a defendant’s right to a fair trial including the essential right to dispute an accusation.

A high-profile case such as the Russell Brand case also gives us the opportunity to highlight the tireless work undertaken by barristers and judges who undertake cases in this difficult and demanding area of legal practice. Whether prosecuting or defending, or presiding as a judge, this is work of immense value both to the public and to the individuals involved in such cases. The public need to understand that these cases are taking place day-in, day-out in courts all over the country. They are just as important to those affected as any other RASSO case which hits the headlines.

We should also take the time publicly to thank and value the work of those members of the public who perform public duty as jurors deciding these cases. It is not an easy task for them.

Members may already have seen comments in the news from many experienced criminal barristers and former judges, including CBA Chair Andrew Thomas KC, CBA Vice Chair Kama Melly KC and former CBA chair Caroline Goodwin KC, pointing out the active steps which are taken in trials to ensure that appropriate directions are given according to the facts of the case. Baroness Carr has also reminded us that the Court of Appeal has been advocating the use of such directions since 2008 and that there is comprehensive guidance on directing the juries on ‘the dangers of assumptions’ in Chapter 20 of the Crown Court Compendium. Extensive powers to control the admission of evidence and the conduct of cross examination already exist in the common law rules of evidence, in statute, in the Criminal Procedure Rules and the Criminal Practice Direction.

As a profession, we must never be complacent. We are not above scrutiny. We acknowledge that consistency can be improved and that we should be vigilant to ensure the highest standards in all cases. The document which should be at the heart of the debate is the Law Commission’s Final Report on Evidence in Sexual Offence Prosecutions. A copy can be found here.

This was a 600-page report based on more than three and a half years of detailed research and consultation. It documents the developments which have taken place over the past 20 years and for the most part finds that the system is operating well. Poor practice is rare, and it is rapidly called out. Nonetheless, the Law Commission’s report identifies areas of weakness and contains recommendations for reform which the CBA has welcomed.

The Law Commission were clear that cases of rape should always be tried by a jury (Recommendation 70), which remains the case even under the Government’s proposals in the Courts and Tribunal Bill.

There has been media speculation that a barrister who relied upon ‘rape myths’ could face a referral to the BSB for serious misconduct, and it has been reported that the Government have written to the BSB about this. A fair and balanced discussion of this issue can be found in the Law Commission’s report. They acknowledge that deliberately or recklessly advancing false information could in theory amount to misleading the court (ie. the jury) but suggest that it could only occur in a ‘deliberate’ and ‘egregious’ case. They acknowledge a barrister’s duty to test the evidence. They acknowledge the high threshold which a complaint would have to reach. They suggest that the BSB Code could be amended to clarify the issue.

‘Myths and stereotypes’ are first and foremost a matter of cultural awareness, and widespread media coverage is therefore to be welcomed. The guideline direction to juries, as per the Compendium, begins with the words: “It would be understandable if some of you came to this trial with assumptions about the crime of rape”.

The modern courtroom is where such myths get debunked, not where they are created.

Reporting of PECS delays

The CBA and the Bar Council are continuing to collect examples of delays in getting people in custody into court.

If you experience a delay, please use the reporting form and share it with your colleagues.

Please continue to report any delays you experience. This exercise is necessary because the structure of the official data-gathering does not provide a reliable indication of the real-world impact of these delays. We need this data both to advance our arguments to Government and to the PECS providers.

The Skills of Modern Advocacy: a new book by Jaime Hamilton KC and Nigel Booth

Over the decades, there have been some outstanding books on advocacy. Classic texts still include John Munkman’s ‘Techniques of Advocacy’ [1951], Richard DuCann KC’s ‘Art of the Advocate’ [1964], Keith Evan’s wonderfully simple ‘Golden Rules of Advocacy [1993] and more recently Mary Cowe and Susan Cavender’s ‘Practical Advocacy in the Crown Court [2020].

There is now another excellent book to add to the pantheon. Jaime Hamilton KC (former leader of the Northern Circuit) and Nigel Booth, now a Programme for the Bar Practice Course at the University of Law, and formerly a leading criminal barrister, have published their brand new book ‘The Skills of Modern Advocacy’, bringing the learning on the techniques of advocacy up to date.

Details of the book are here.

The book is aimed at students through to early years practitioners. Jaime and Nigel have kindly offered a 20% discount for all CBA members, with the discount code: 26ESA4.

In his preface, the Common Sergeant of London, Richard Marks KC, says:

“An up-to-date book on advocacy has been very long overdue. I commend this excellent exposition to the reader, whether they are just embarking on a career as an advocate or are already experienced.”

Courts and Tribunals Bill: House of Lords Committee Stage (first session)

On Tuesday 10 November 2026, members of the House of Lords further debated the Court and Tribunals Bill at Committee stage, considering a raft of amendments put forward by peers from all the major parties.

You can read peers’ contributions in full here, via Hansard.

The Committee Stage Debate

Baroness Chakrabarti (Labour) opened the debate by dealing with a series of proposed amendments to defeat or mitigate the removal of the right to elect in Clause 1 of the Bill. She warned of an unintended consequence of abolishing election: that defendants of good character facing shorter likely sentences would be less likely to receive jury trial than those with many previous convictions. She stressed that ordinary people trust juries more than other institutions, and that juries provide vindication for the wrongly accused and for victims. On judge-alone fraud trials, she criticised the 'public interest' test as broad, amorphous and hard to review or litigate, arguing that any such power should turn on the narrower interests of justice.

Viscount Hailsham (Douglas Hogg KC) supported the in-principle opposition to the removal of the right to elect. Acknowledging the possibility that the Government’s majority might force it through Parliament, he argued that the House of Lords should try to remedy the Bill’s faults and omissions. He argued that the right to jury trial in either way offences enjoys widespread professional and public support, with little appetite for change, so altering it demands the most compelling reasons, which he said do not exist. Jury trials are not the principal cause of the Crown Court backlog. Administrative action could address delay instead, and simply displacing a backlog from the Crown Court to the magistrates' courts was not self-evidently sensible.

Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd (Cross Bench) echoed concerns made clear by the CBA, that many of the cases being shifted from the Crown Court will not just lose a jury, they will be decided by judge alone using District Judges instead. He also questioned whether the case had been made that this would be more efficient. He said: “…an issue that has not much been debated so far: are the cases that are retained in the magistrates’ courts to be decided by three magistrates or by judge alone—that is, by a district judge or deputy district judges? Lord Thomas asked the Government to make their intentions clear: “… in deciding whether it is retained in the magistrates’ court, does it matter that it is to be trial by judge alone, or is it irrelevant whether it is trial by judge alone or trial before three magistrates? Many people have confidence in lay participation in the administration of justice and the knowledge of the community that they bring with them”… We owe it in fairness to people to understand that although they may have thought that trial by judge alone had gone, it may be that trial by judge alone will be fairly common under the new system.” He agreed with Lord Leveson that there is plainly a block of offences which could be reclassified as summary-only, and urged the Government to consider this. “We urge that reclassification be considered as one of the options in trying to find a way forward that achieves a consensus on how we transfer more cases to the magistrates’ courts and relieve the pressure on the Crown Court, because that should certainly be done.”

Baroness Jones (Green) made clear her desire to “oppose a lot of the clauses in the Bill”. She said: “The right to elect trial by jury is an important safeguard. This clause removes that choice and hands the decision to magistrates. I have great respect for magistrates—I know quite a few and I appreciate the work they do—but that is not the issue here. The issue is whether a defendant should lose the choice of having their case heard by a jury. The Government argue that this is necessary to tackle the Crown Court backlog, but as we have already heard, removing rights is not a substitute for properly resourcing our courts. It is not going to work; that is fairly obvious from the debates we have had already.” She spoke about her disappointment at the Government’s failure to address equality considerations. “Their own equality statement acknowledges that Black defendants, older defendants and women are more likely to elect for a Crown Court trial. In 2022, 26% of Black defendants elected for a Crown Court trial, compared with 15% of white defendants. The Lammy Review found that many people from ethnic-minority backgrounds had ‘more confidence in the fairness of juries than … in the fairness of Magistrates’ Courts’. So removing this choice risks further undermining confidence in a justice system where trust is already quite fragile.”

Baroness Mallalieu KC (Labour) said: “There is a big difference when you are facing a trial as to which you would opt for. Which one of us would opt for the magistrates rather than a jury trial? It is a different standard of justice”. She expressed her support for the work of magistrates, but referred to the higher standard of preparation which is given to a Crown Court case. She said most defendants would choose jury trial and removing appeal rights on allocation would deny justice.

Former DPP, Lord Macdonald of River Glaven KC (Cross Bench), questioned whether magistrates' courts could cope with the extra work. He agreed with Lord Leveson that backlogs stem not only from underfunding and Covid but also from the growing complexity and volume of evidence, yet asked why such cases would be any less complicated in the magistrates' courts. Many urban magistrates' courts were already in chaos, with growing backlogs. Without significant funding and allocation guidelines, as proposed in Amendment 2, magistrates might simply send everything to the Crown Court. He criticised successive Governments' reprehensible underfunding of justice.

Baroness Levitt KC supported the removal of the right to elect, saying the central question was whether Parliament trusts magistrates. She described magistrates as one of the great strengths of the criminal justice system, every day determining guilt, passing sentence and making decisions affecting liberty, livelihoods and futures. If they can be trusted with those responsibilities, she asked, why should they not be trusted to decide where a case is tried? She said opponents of Clause 1 had not answered that satisfactorily. Clause 1 asks for no radical new judicial function, only a modest decision compared with the responsibilities magistrates already discharge every single day.

Baroness Hamwee (Liberal Democrat), a former solicitor, focused on the Government’s intention to remove automatic rights of appeal from the Magistrates’ court. She stated: “As the Law Society put it, speed should not be the only criterion where a person “may be convicted and sentenced to a lengthy period of custody or suffer life-changing reputational damage”. To me, the issue of reputation is hugely important. We tend to focus on the length of a sentence, but I think any sentence carries a reputational factor. Following a short summary trial, there is a serious risk that efficiency will be perceived to have come at the expense of fairness.”

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames KC (Liberal Democrat) described jury trial as a cornerstone of liberty and protection against arbitrary power, trusted because twelve jurors deliberating privately are likelier to reach fair results than one judge. Juries also democratise justice. He opposed removing the right of election on grounds of backlog reduction, when other measures are working and the supporting evidence is painfully thin. He acknowledged that magistrates try about 90% of cases, but that figure largely reflects motoring and low-level offences, whereas serious Crown Court cases deserve everything a jury provides. He said: “People do not necessarily get the same quality of justice, for exactly the reasons that the noble Baroness, Lady Mallalieu, explained. Serious cases deserve serious effort and attention. They also deserve everything that the jury gives: the privacy of the jury room, the care taken to the evidence, the guidance of a Crown Court judge and the lack of differential between one judge and another. The reason that people trust juries is, I believe, largely to do with the bald fact that 12 heads are better than one.”

Lord Keen of Elie KC (Conservative) criticised the Courts Minister's remark that courts, not criminals, should triage cases, warning that describing all defendants as criminals risked losing sight of the presumption of innocence, which must not yield to backlog convenience. He affirmed his Benches' commitment to the ancient right to jury trial, recalling the House's opposition to similar Labour proposals in the 2000s, and suggested the Bill was driven more by ideology than evidence. Citing Baroness Jones and Lord Marks, he said the Government had not justified the proposals, and asked what evidence showed they would cut backlogs and how magistrates' courts would avoid being overwhelmed. He said: “In addition, it seems likely to us that these measures will simply move the backlog from the Crown Court to the magistrates’ court, as other noble Lords have observed. …how much do the Government expect these measures to impact the magistrates’ system and what measures are being taken to avoid that system being overwhelmed by these measures?”

For the Government, Baroness Smith of Cluny argued that Clause 1 removes defendants' ability to elect Crown Court trial for all either way offences, so venue decisions rest solely with courts based on seriousness and complexity, ‘rebalancing matters between victims and defendants’. She said the Bill responds to concerns about public confidence and will prioritise Crown Court time for the most serious cases, sparing victims delay. Magistrates' courts are fair, robust and independent, and safeguards remain, including representations on venue and appeal rights. She said that the Government aims to nearly double the magistrates' complement by 2028-29.

Lord Lemos, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, said that the Government were not minded to support the reclassification of offences because of the impact on investigative powers and because some of the offences concerned involved tackling violence against women and girls, which remains a priority for the Government. He said that he was willing to engage in discussion with Lord Thomas and Lord Leveson on the issue.

Lord Carlile of Berriew KC expressed great respect for jury trials, drawing on his experience as both prosecutor and defender. He spoke to his amendment, which would create a new right for defendants to apply for, though not to select, trial by judge alone. He argued that the right to seek trial by judge alone should sit alongside the right to seek trial by jury.

Lord Leveson of Liverpool invited peers to read the reports of his Independent Review of the Criminal Courts. On trial by Judge alone in long and complex cases, he emphasised the importance of judicial discretion and said that he could well understand circumstances in which a judge would feel that it was not appropriate for a trial to take place without a jury. Lord Lemos said that the Government were seeking the power to trial long and complex cases without a jury not because of the competence of juries to try such cases but because of the burden which they created for juries. “This is not about who can understand dishonesty better but about reducing the burden on ordinary people’s lives from sitting on long trials.” He said that the Government agreed in principle with many of the recommendations in Jonathan Fisher KC’s report on Fraud in the Digital Age and said that the use of trial by judge alone in such cases would be “exceptional”.

The Bill returns for further debate on Monday 16th November 2026.

The CBA’s position

The CBA have warned that should clauses 1 to 7 remain as drafted by Government, the successful efforts of the criminal Bar, solicitors and judiciary to reduce delays for cases and address backlogs in the Crown Court will be undone, leading to further chaos in the magistrates’ Courts, more delays and a rise in miscarriages of justice. This undermine public faith in the criminal justice system.

CBA members both prosecute and defend. We are attuned to the varying interests of complainants, defendants and other participants in the criminal justice system. The views we express, supported by our 2025 members’ survey, are clear: justice needs juries. They are the central pillar of our system of criminal justice, and the verdict of a jury remains the gold standard for justice. That is why we say:

  • Other than for summary-only offences, we should retain a citizen’s right to elect trial by a jury of their peers.

  • We can deal with truly minor offences by reclassifying some existing either way offences as summary-only.

  • The limit on magistrates’ court sentencing powers should remain at 12 months. Magistrates’ courts are not equipped to deal with the trial of more serious, more complex cases. Transferring tens of thousands of such cases will result in miscarriages of justice.

  • The automatic right to appeal should be retained as an important safeguard - 56% of contested appeals against conviction from summary trials are successful. The caseload is low and the current simple procedure is accessible to all.

Let there be absolutely no doubt: the CBA is committed to reducing Crown Court backlogs and addressing delays. We have been voicing our concerns about the backlog since 2020, long before the MoJ took action to prevent the worsening position. Our simple point is that it is not trial by jury which has caused the backlog, and the tireless work of barristers and judges has already brought the Crown Court backlog under control. Meanwhile, the backlog in the magistrates’ courts is already surging upwards, and it makes no sense to move cases from the Crown Court queue to a different and worsening queue in the magistrates’ courts.

Criminal Law Week: updates (issue 41)

Key updates from this week’s issue of Criminal Law Week:

  • Sexual history evidence – whether deficiencies of the defence case at trial in relation to a complainant’s sexual history and bad character were such as to render the appellant’s conviction for rape unreliable: R. v Ahmed (Nazir), CLW/26/41/2, CA.

  • Victim personal statement – case and comment on the use of AI to prepare a victim personal statement in the context of sentencing for domestic abuse: R. v Gibson, CLW/26/41/3, CA.

  • Restraint order – case and comment on an application to discharge a restraint order under the Proceeds of Crime Act 2002 where proceedings for the offence have not been commenced within a reasonable time: R. v Bewley, CLW/26/41/10, CA.

  • Murder – sentencing case where the appellant had armed himself with a knife in a pub kitchen before fatally stabbing the deceased, who had come to the pub in search of a fight and armed with a BB gun: R. v Cosier, CLW/26/41/5, CA.

Andrew Thomas KC

Chair
The Criminal Bar Association

Kama Melly KC

Vice Chair
The Criminal Bar Association