Skip to content
The Criminal Bar Association

Year in Review

Year in Review – 2025

The year at a glance

2025 was, by some distance, the most consequential year for the criminal Bar since the Days of Action of 2022. The independent review of the criminal courts conducted by Sir Brian Leveson reported in early July, setting in train a fundamental national debate about the future of jury trial in England and Wales. Against the backdrop of a Crown Court backlog that pushed standard bail trial dates to four years away from charge, a Legal Aid Agency cyber-attack that knocked the funding portal offline for months, the publication of Baroness Harriet Harman KC's report on bullying and harassment at the Bar, and a mid-year change at the helm of the Ministry of Justice, the Association found itself defending the constitutional foundations of the criminal trial while continuing to fight the long campaign on fees, conditions, and retention.

Who was Chair

For the first two-thirds of the calendar year the Chair was Mary Prior KC of 36 Group Chambers (term September 2024 to August 2025), with Riel Karmy-Jones KC of Red Lion Chambers as her Vice-Chair. On 1st September 2025 Riel Karmy-Jones KC took up the chairmanship for the 2025 to 2026 term, with Andrew Thomas KC of Lincoln House Chambers, Manchester as Vice-Chair. The handover was marked in the Monday Message of 8th September 2025, in which the new officer team paid tribute to Mary Prior KC's two-year contribution as Vice-Chair and then Chair, observing that "the personal respect all justice stakeholders have when listening to her wise, informed views" had been one of the defining features of her tenure.

Key themes

The Leveson Review and the jury trial debate

No issue dominated the year as completely as Sir Brian Leveson KC's Independent Review of the Criminal Courts. The Association's substantive response to Part 1 – addressing whether jury trial should be restricted to reduce the backlog – was drafted by a working group led by Jeremy Dein KC and Francis Fitzgibbon KC, with contributions from advocates across England and Wales. The Monday Message of 20th January reported the very tight government deadline for submissions and asked members to provide additional points by the end of that day. The full CBA response was published shortly afterwards and was repeatedly cited in subsequent Monday Messages.

Sir Brian's Part 1 report was published in early July. To capture the criminal Bar's view of his specific recommendations – in particular the proposed Crown Court Bench Division (CCBD) sitting without juries – the Association commissioned an independent snap survey from Professor Katrin Hohl of City St George's, University of London. The survey was deliberately designed to be neutral: all response options commenced with "support", then "neutral", then "negative". Over the seven days it was open, 2,029 criminal barristers responded. Professor Hohl described the response rate as "phenomenal" in both absolute and relative terms. The headline findings, summarised in the Monday Message of 28th July, showed approximately 90% of criminal barristers opposed restrictions on the right to jury trial; 77.6% considered that any CCBD must be piloted first; and only 5.9% were not at all concerned about diversity in any new CCBD. This survey became the Association's evidential cornerstone for the rest of the year.

In September Sir Brian embarked on Part 2 of his review – the efficiency review – and the new officer team began engaging with him on the implementation of his Part 1 recommendations. By November, with leaked Ministry of Justice memoranda hinting at the form a government response might take, the Association moved onto the front foot of a media campaign. Riel Karmy-Jones KC's Monday Message of 24th November addressed, point by point, the use of the Canadian criminal justice system as a comparator in MoJ briefings, observing that any cherry-picking of a system whose foundation is "the right of an accused person to ELECT trial by jury" was "wholly misleading".

The Crown Court backlog and the court estate

The backlog and the sitting day cap were treated by the Association as the cause of the crisis the Leveson Review was being asked to solve. In the Monday Message of 12th May the Chair reported that Resident Judges at Wood Green and Isleworth had written to inform members that trials originally listed for two years' time were now to be heard in three years' time, and that "Rape cases will wait two years for a trial. Standard bail cases will wait three years." By September 2025 some courts were setting trial dates over four years from the date of charge.

The condition of the court estate ran alongside this. The Monday Message of 3rd February pointed to "leaking ceilings, infestations, freezing court rooms and cells, technology failures, broken lifts and unsafe spaces" and called for the cap on Crown Court sitting days to be lifted, for mothballed courts to be reopened, and for unused parts of existing buildings (catering facilities and the like) to be remodelled to increase capacity. Those eight immediate proposals submitted to Leveson would recur as a refrain throughout the year.

The Sentencing Review and the Sentencing Bill

The Association's response to the David Gauke-led Sentencing Review, published in early 2025, was prepared in parallel with the Leveson response. The CBA endorsed the supplementary submissions of Rachel Barnes KC on sentencing for neurodivergent and neurodisabled defendants. When the Sentencing Bill was published in early September it gave effect to most of the Gauke recommendations. In the Monday Message of 8th September the Chair welcomed in particular its proposals to strengthen community punishments, given that prisons were full to capacity, while committing to careful scrutiny of the detail. By 15th September the Chair's comments to The Times – on the proposed power to veto rules issued by the Sentencing Council – were exercising the Association's principal media voice on the Bill's more constitutional features.

The Legal Aid Agency cyber-attack

On 23rd April 2025 the Legal Aid Agency became aware that its digital services had been the subject of a cyber-attack. By 16th May the Ministry of Justice and the LAA had recognised that the breach was significantly more extensive than first understood, and the online portal was taken down. Members of the public who had applied for legal aid at any time since 2010 were urged to be alert for suspicious activity. The Submit a Crime Form was eventually restored to service on 16th September. As reported in the Monday Message of 22nd September, additional resourcing was put into the Magistrates Billing Team to process the backlog of CRM4 applications for prior authority. The Association acknowledged the MoJ and LAA teams who had been working "around the clock", but the episode underlined the fragility of the publicly funded infrastructure on which the criminal Bar depends.

Bullying, harassment, and the CBA National Survey

The CBA National Survey 2025 was launched in February and closed at midnight on 3rd March 2025. It was led by Riel Karmy-Jones KC as Vice-Chair, supported by Mark Watson and Chloë Ashley, and stress-tested by a wider group including Andrew Thomas KC, James Gray, Eleanor Mawrey, Paramjit Ahluwalia, Sally Hobson and James Oliveira-Agnew. As reported in subsequent Monday Messages, the findings on bullying and harassment were sobering: 60% of women criminal barristers and 32% of men reported experiencing such conduct from a colleague at Chambers or at Court; 79% of Black, 71% of Mixed heritage and 55% of Asian criminal barristers reported the same; 54% of practitioners with a disability; and 45% of those not privately educated. There was no evidence that things were improving for the current Junior Bar.

Those findings were quoted with grim resonance when, on 8th September 2025, the Bar Council published Baroness Harriet Harman KC's independent report on Bullying, Harassment and Sexual Harassment at the Bar. The CBA welcomed the report and, in language that was unusually direct, observed that one of the case examples within it was the conduct of a past Chair of the Association. The reference was to Jo Sidhu KC, who had been disbarred by the Bar Standards Board on 19th March 2025 in respect of three charges of professional misconduct relating to a female mini-pupillage student in November 2018. The finding and sanction were subject to appeal at the time of writing.

Consultations responded to

  • CBA Response to the Independent Review of the Criminal Courts (the Leveson Review) Part 1, January 2025, led by Jeremy Dein KC and Francis Fitzgibbon KC. Eight immediate proposals included removing the Crown Court sitting day cap, reopening mothballed courts and investing in the court estate.
  • CBA Response to the Independent Sentencing Review (the Gauke Review), early 2025, with adopted supplementary submissions by Rachel Barnes KC on sentencing concerns for the neurodivergent and neurodisabled community.
  • Justice Select Committee inquiry into the use of pre-recorded cross-examination under Section 28 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999. Kama Melly KC, Chair of the RASSO Sub-Committee, gave oral evidence on behalf of the Association in September 2025.
  • House of Lords Select Committee inquiry on police transcription (autumn 2025).
  • Initial CBA response to Sir Brian Leveson's Review Part 2 was being prepared at year end (the full review was published 4th February 2026).

Notable events

The CBA Annual Dinner was held on 16th May 2025 in Inner Temple Hall. The guest speaker was the Right Honourable Lord Justice Green, the Senior Presiding Judge. The CBA Education Conference took place on Saturday 3rd May 2025 – its theme was appeals from every criminal court – with over a hundred members of the criminal Bar in attendance at their own expense. The Director of Education, Paul Jarvis KC, and his committee organised the programme; the Monday Message of 12th May recorded "our thanks go to […] Aaron Dolan for flawless organisation of another first class event".

The South Eastern Circuit's Tim Dutton CBE KC Advanced International Advocacy Course at Keble College ran successfully in late August. The Bar Council Annual Conference took place in Birmingham on 7th June 2025, preceded by a Bar Mess on the Friday evening. The first CBA Young Bar Day, conceived by the Young Bar Sub-Committee, took place on Saturday 11th October 2025 at Inner Temple, with the keynote delivered by Lady Justice Whipple and a faculty including Mrs Justice Maura McGowan, HHJ Noel Lucas, HHJ Rosa Dean, HHJ Emma Nott, Ben Aina KC, Sarah Clarke KC, Sam Skinner KC, Claire Davies KC, Heidi Stonecliffe KC and Thom Dyke. The Northern Pupillage Fair at Manchester Metropolitan University attracted over 500 registered visitors and more than 40 stands. The CBA podcast series continued through the year, including a year-end conversation between Mary Prior KC and Barbara Mills KC, Chair of the Bar Council.

Government and regulatory landscape

The first half of 2025 saw the Association working with the Labour Government's first Lord Chancellor, Shabana Mahmood, and with Sarah Sackman KC MP as Minister of State. The minister attended the first session of the Criminal Legal Aid Advisory Board (CLAAB) in January 2025, chaired by HH Deborah Taylor. Fortnightly meetings between the CBA Officers and the MoJ continued through the spring. On 28th July the Chair reported that the MoJ was considering "the possibility of multi-year funding settlements for the criminal Bar" and that more would be said in the Autumn.

The Cabinet reshuffle of early September 2025 changed the personnel. David Lammy MP was appointed Deputy Prime Minister, Lord Chancellor and Secretary of State for Justice; Shabana Mahmood moved to the Home Office. The CBA congratulated both, and recorded its appreciation of Ms Mahmood's tenure both in government and previously in opposition. The Lord Chancellor's first major decision affecting the criminal Bar's immediate constituency was on judicial pay: the Senior Salaries Review Body had recommended 4.75%; the Lord Chancellor gave 4%. The SSRB had pointed to a marked rise in judicial workloads, the poor condition of the court estate and persistent difficulty in filling judicial vacancies – the district judge campaign had filled only 51 of 100 vacancies.

The Serious Fraud Office announced fee uplifts at the end of August: 25% across all counsel on the SFO panels, with a smaller increase of 4.25% on disclosure work to reflect a previous 21% uplift in December 2023. The full new rates took effect from 1st September 2025.

Other regulatory developments of note included the Law Commission's final report on Evidence in Sexual Offences Prosecutions, the Bar Council's Working Lives study (which showed criminal practitioners reporting higher prevalence of bullying and harassment across all call bands than other branches of the Bar), and the appointment of Claire Waxman OBE as Victims' Commissioner from 1st January 2026, with Baroness Helen Newlove continuing to year end. The Chair of the Bar Council, Barbara Mills KC, worked in close co-operation with the CBA throughout, and at year end Heidi Stonecliffe KC of the Crown Prosecution Service was elected Vice-Chair of the Bar Council to succeed Kirsty Brimelow KC (former CBA Chair, 2022 to 2023) when Kirsty took the Bar Council chairmanship in 2026.

In memoriam

The year saw the loss of several distinguished members of the profession. Tim Dutton CBE KC, who founded the South Eastern Circuit Advanced International Advocacy Course at Keble College in 1994 and was awarded the CBE in 2015 for his contribution to the profession and to the law, died in 2025 after some eleven years of living with motor neurone disease. His motto, "Treat every day as if it were the last", was recalled in the Monday Message of 9th June, alongside tributes from Claire Davies KC, Leader of the South Eastern Circuit. The Keble course now bears his name.

Lord Justice William Davis died on the morning of 7th June 2025. Called to the Bar by Inner Temple in 1975, he took Silk in 1998, sat as Recorder of Birmingham from 2009, became a High Court Judge in 2014 (Presider of the Northern Circuit 2016 to 2019), Judicial Lead for Youth Justice 2014 to 2022, and was elevated to the Court of Appeal on 1st October 2021.

Her Honour Valerie Pearlman CBE died in August 2025, aged 89. Called to the Bar in 1958 – at a time when there were fewer than 100 women practising and no female judges – she became a Circuit Judge in 1985, the thirteenth woman in England and Wales to be appointed to the full-time judiciary. Conor Gearty KC (Hon) also died in 2025; he was a noted human rights scholar long associated with the Bar.

Looking ahead from the time

The Monday Messages of the late autumn flagged three priorities for the year ahead: defending the right to jury trial through the Parliamentary process expected on the Government's response to Leveson Part 1; engagement with Sir Brian's Part 2 (the efficiency review), which was published on 4th February 2026; and implementation of Baroness Harman's recommendations on culture and conduct at the Bar. As the new Chair put it on 15th September, "this has been the year for reviews, and it goes without saying that the next two years will be critical for our profession."

← Back to Year in Review